MEMBER LOGIN
email

password

forgot password?
     
 
SIGN UP FOR FANZAK
 
INVITED TO FANZAK?
     

yerblues 2 Comments 3126 Read Apr 30, 2009


Barry Bonds should be in the Hall of Fame.  So should Roger Clemens.  And Mark McGwire.  Even Sammy Sosa.  And one day, Alex Rodriguez, right?  Right?

There.

I said it.

Admittedly, my opinion is not a popular one, nor one that I'm particularly proud of.  I do think these players, to a certain extent, cheated the game of baseball.  But so did hundreds of other lower-profile players (who cares if Adam Piatt or Ryan Franklin did PEDs by the boatload, right?).  Sure, they ("allegedly") decided to increase their already-talented bodies' performance with steroids of various grades and human growth hormones.  While I think they made the wrong moral decision, they simply did what baseball owners, scouts, general managers, and field managers "encouraged" them to do.  The entire baseball industry, from the fans and batboys to the sportscasters and journalists who cover the sport, knew that the bulked up bodies of these baseball players were sending balls out of yard at record clips year after year, but nobody, out of all those people, expressed any concern until, what, 2004?  I just don't see why these players should be ostracized for doing what we as fans wanted them to do: hit massive, awe-inspiring home runs.  Now, all of the sudden, we have turned on these players when we were, all along, complicit in their use?  Now we're taking the moral high ground?

The biggest problem for Bonds, Clemens, McGwire, and Sosa is that they have been caught in lies, botched Nixonian coverups, or non-answers regarding their use of PEDs.  Clearly their actions suggest guilt.  We as Americans are taught that people are "innocent until proven guilty," but when dealing with these four athletes, it seems that that maxim has been reversed.  If only they would have told the truth, right?  People said that for years about Pete Rose, whose baseball sin was, to me, much more egregious than these four players.  Unfortunately, he waited way too long to admit guilt for his crime, and made the admission during the weekend of a Hall of Fame admission ceremony, once again leaving Rose to look like an opportunist hawking his third book on the subject rather than a person showing repentance for their past sins.

Today, more revelations came out about Alex Rodriguez's alleged use of PEDs, both before and after the time he admitted to using them (from 2001 to 2003, while he was with the Texas Rangers).

I remember when he first admitted to using steroids in February how elated I was that one of the game's true superstars during the "Steroid Era" actually admitted to using.  After all, we are "forgiving country," or so they say, right?  But then, some good reporting revealed that there were holes in A-Rod's story: lots of them.  So what's worse: Lying about everything, or only telling some of the truth and lying about much more of the story?

This is where we are at with Alex Rodriguez.  Last year, when the achievements of Roger Clemens seemingly disappeared before our very eyes, I thought to myself there's no way anybody can do more damage to their baseball career than this guy.  Well, one year later, I've been proven wrong ... BIG TIME.  A-Rod has been caught using steroids, has admitted to using them, has been caught lying about what he knew or didn't know about the drugs, has been divorced, linked with the buff, old, has-been Kabbala-poser Madonna, and has been photographed basically making out with himself in a mirror in the pages of Details magazine.  Could things get any worse for this guy? Yes.  He could have a subpar season in New York City, where fans jump off the bandwagon after an 0-1 start to a 162 game season.  If A-Rod can overcome all of this and make it to Cooperstown some day, I, seriously, will be a monkey's uncle.

So what's the lesson in all of this?  1) Tell the truth?  2) You can't have your long-ball cake and eat it too?  3) Maple bats, Lasix, smaller ballparks, weight-lifting, and harder baseballs are Performance Enhancers too?  The greatest lesson here is essentially a sad one: the greatest baseball players of my life have ruined their reputations doing what we wanted them to do.  And while it's perfectly understandable, in my opinion, that doesn't make them right for doing so either.

Tags:
Alex Rodriguez, MLB, Barry Bonds, Mark McGwire, Roger Clemens, MLB , NY Yankees (MLB), MLB , Rangers (MLB), MLB , Cardinals (MLB)

Share This Story: Yahoo Blogmarks Del.icio.us Google Spurl Furl Live
Digg
Alger says on Sunday, June 21st at 5:10am

Greeting. As a well-spent day brings happy sleep, so life well used brings happy death. Help me! Please help find sites for: Lamisil at antifungal. I found only this - Lamisil homepage. Lamisil tablet dosage form should not be prescribed for patients with pre existing liver disease, rare cases of hepatic failure, some leading to death or liver. Lots of detailed information on lamisil and nail fungus. Thank you very much :rolleyes:. Alger from Kazakhstan.

Frank C. Tulku says on Wednesday, May 13th at 6:14pm

I do agree that the whole culture of baseball aided and abetted the use of steriods by the game's best players. However, I do not believe that any of the above-named players should be admitted into the Hall of Fame.

If these players did use performance enhancing drugs, and the evidence seems undeniable that they did, their achievements have been compromised to the extent that they are no longer the game's greatest players in terms of their career accolades. Instead, they represent a group of players who put up incredible numbers while using performance enhancing drugs.

The absence of moral judgment in the conclusion above is deliberate. Fans should make up their own minds about these players' moral characters and decisions. In doing so, though, I believe that fans should recognize the players' humanity.



Leave a Reply










Biography
Brian Flota is a professor of English (specializing in American literature) at a university in the state of Oklahoma. He was born in Southern Illinois during the Gerald Ford administration, but grew up in Southern California's Inland Empire. His favorite athletes are the venerable contact hitter Wade Boggs and the slugging running back John Riggins. He spent all of his allowance money on baseball cards in the late 1980s and early 1990s that are now worth nothing. In his early thirties, he was a standout utility player on Arlington, Virginia's powerhouse co-ed softball squad The Pubfish, providing him with all the insight he would ever need to know about the panacea of professional athletics. He often holds less-than-popular opinions about sports' greatest controversies, but never takes them too seriously.

Fanzak Writers
The Sports Lecture
by Ryan White

Little Giants Big on Gender
Posted 13 weeks ago.
The Sports Orphan
by Justin Brindger

Oh I Wish I was a Professional Baseball Player
Posted 24 weeks ago.
It's All Over But The Crying
by Andrew Lovell

NFL week nine picks
Posted 18 weeks ago.
The Tailgate
by Shae Cronin

Matt Barkley: The Poster Boy Potential
Posted 25 weeks ago.
The Forecheck
by Brendan Coyle

Pittsburgh Penguins are the Stanley Cup Champions.
Posted 39 weeks ago.